---

It's your boat, build it the way you want and enjoy it!

Within reason and as long as it's done well, I don't think there's too much to worry about regarding the "value" or "appreciation" of the boat. Yes, there are people out there who want a fully restored OEM authentic Whaler, but there's plenty of people who want a well maintained, functional, safe, attractive boat they can use and enjoy. Sounds like you and your buddy are working well together and your boat will be beautiful. I can't wait to see how it turns out!

A look at my personal page will show you a 17' hull with a custom swing back seat, an aftermarket console, and no high rails. It's certainly not factory but I get plenty of compliments and more than one person has asked for right of first refusal if I want to sell.

I prefer not having those classic high rails Whalers are famous for. In fact I imagine them being inconvenient when getting people and things on and off board