Thread subject: Whaler Central - Boston Whaler Boat Information and Photos :: Drain tube problems

Posted by litespeed on 03/28/06 - 7:27 PM
#1

I thought I would post this to help others that may be racking there brains over the same problem.

I have been researching drain tubes for weeks here and elsewhere to include local shops and all over the internet.

Finding the factory tubes proved to be pretty easy but I keep hearing how they crack, corrode and fall apart. So I bought the factory tubes with o-rings and was about ready to install them when I thought of PVC. Has anyone tried this?

It is too late for me... I already did it. It just makes more sense all the way around. It is readily available anywhere (IE: Home Depot, Lowes, etc...), it is easy to shape and cut. And it was very easy to install. I had to open up the rear foam about 1/16th of an inch to make room for the pipe. I tapped the 3/4 inch PVC in the hole, marked it, removed it and cut it. Tapped it in with a small hammer. Then I bedded both ends in with 5200. It looks to be a good, easily servicable solution to the brass drains.

The inside drain hole on my boat was pretty worn out so this was a great solution for me. It may prove to be a good solution for others with long drain tubes and or failing brass tubes.

I also plan to use a small piece of poly tubing for the anchor drain. Easily replaceable.

I used the thin wall PVC for the Drains. Not Sch. 40. I really did not see the need for that kind of strength down there. I'll post results good or bad in a few months. The boat will see a lot of abuse over the next few months during scalloping season, lobster season and the other fishing seasons.....

AJ

Edited by litespeed on 03/28/06 - 7:28 PM

Posted by MW on 03/29/06 - 12:56 AM
#2

Absolutely "GENIUS" ! ! ! and I need to replace the drain tube too ! With idea's like this, I'm glad that you're on the side of "GOOD" Not "EVIL". Thanks ! MW

Posted by drandlett on 03/29/06 - 4:37 AM
#3

AJ- seems like a great idea. could you give more details on how you were able to seal the inboard and outboard edges of the PVC to the hull? it seems like it would be hard to create a solid seal.

Thanks dana

Posted by litespeed on 03/29/06 - 6:53 AM
#4

drandlett wrote:
AJ- seems like a great idea. could you give more details on how you were able to seal the inboard and outboard edges of the PVC to the hull? it seems like it would be hard to create a solid seal.

Thanks dana


Dana,

It is a real tight fit on the outside. A little looser on the inside as you can see in the photo. I actually had to tap it in with a small sledge hammer. The outside does not even need sealant. But I sealed both ends in and out. I smeared some slow cure 5200 (blue) on my finger and ran it just inside the holes before inserting the pipe. Then I seal the outer edge with a little more and created a small lip wit the 5200. It is self leveling so it looks real professional. If for some reason it should start to peel off (it should'nt) it is easy to repair. And it will not leak because it is sealed on the inside too.

I hammered a 14" piece of that 3/4" thin wall PVC all the way through the hole so I could mark the pipe with a fine pencil. But first I had to remove a tiny amount of foam on the bottom of the hole to get the right angle to go all the way through. After marking the pipe and removing it again....... I cut just behind the lines on the hacksaw and then finished the rough edges with sandpaper. When the pipe is in the boat, it sits about 1mm inside the holes on both ends. I did this in case it gets bumped by an obstruction (nothing to bump or break).

This is a much better solution for me. If this does give me problems again it will be VERY easy to fix. And I can get the material right down the street.

The best part is that there are no specialized tools or parts required. I'm taking the brass tubes and o-rings back.

I am going to pull the tubes after the summer (about 4 months) and check the foam with a moisture meter. It is bone dry right now.

I'll post a photo of the finished job on Friday. The boat is in a freinds garage right now. It looks real nice. I would not do it if it looked bad or if I thought I would compromise the durability of my boat. This boat will get a lot of use. So it is important that it is right.

AJ

Posted by drandlett on 03/29/06 - 2:56 PM
#5

Thanks AJ, think i'll be trying the same thing on my 17' when i next get the chance.

Dana

Posted by drandlett on 03/31/06 - 4:25 AM
#6

AJ,

This may be a silly question but I am hesitant when it comes to exposing the inner foam etc. How do you get the old brass drain tube out without damaging the gel coat or making either the inboard or outboard holes larger?

Thanks,
Dana

Posted by litespeed on 03/31/06 - 6:04 AM
#7

Dana,

I gently collapsed the tubes with a medium sized screwdriver and a hammer. Very Carefully! You dont want to slip and scratch the GelCoat or Paint. If the boat has been painted you will want to take a razor knife and cut the paint around the drain first.

It seemed to work best to collapse the tube in several places and not just in one big spot.

Collapse the side that you will not be pulling from. IE: on my 13 the lower drain tube cannot come out on the inside so I collapsed the tube on the inside and pushed it out the back of the boat. It may take a little light tapping with a hammer to get it moving. But, once it is moving..... It will just slide right out.

I have the boat back in my yard now. I'll post a photo of the finished tube later today.

AJ

Edited by litespeed on 03/31/06 - 6:10 AM

Posted by kevin nolan on 03/31/06 - 1:45 PM
#8

cool its now my turn to try but i think im going to go with the brass tube and o rings for 14 dollers and rent the flaring tool from a marina here for 5 dollers. so for 20 bucks. it will be new and original. thank so much kevin

Posted by litespeed on 04/02/06 - 7:43 AM
#9

Dana,

Here is the finished drain. The "caulk bead" is bigger on the inside because of the size of the hole. If you dont have any damage around the hole...... The caulk bead will be much smaller. The caulk bead on the rear is barely visible.

The boat has already been used so it is dirty.....

AJ

Edited by litespeed on 04/02/06 - 8:08 AM

Posted by kevin nolan on 04/03/06 - 11:43 AM
#10

I did my drain tube I don't like it but it will do. I think if I was to do it over I would put it through from the inside out mark the tube at the out side of transom and cut it 1/8 inch at the same angle of the mark around the tube. The flare on the outside never changed so it's at a 45 degree angle and the transom is not so I have space at the bottom of the tube between the transom and the flare the top is tight and the inside flare is perfect because I cut it at an angle. Oh, and both O-rings came off so I hope the 5200 3m is good stuff or I'll get water in my hull. Hope this helps someone.
Live and learn.

Kevin

Edited by Tom W Clark on 04/04/06 - 8:30 AM

Posted by Tom W Clark on 04/04/06 - 8:34 AM
#11

Kevin,

You absolutely should always cut the tube at the same angle as the hull. This is very important.

If you are using the O-rings (and you should) you need more than 1/8" extra sticking out of the hull. I recommend 5/16" extra with the O-ring on the opposing side in place. This allows enough extra tubing to create the flare and cover the 1/8" O-ring.

In your case I suggest you dig out the tube and try again. It's a simple matter and now that you're warmed up you will be able to do it right.

Posted by litespeed on 04/04/06 - 3:16 PM
#12

Kevin,

Heed Tom's advice here! This is important!!

If there is any doubt that it may leak..... DO NOT PUT IT IN THE WATER!!...

My boat spent over 6 months in a warehouse drying out because of a leak in this area.

My main concern in your case would be if the tubing split. This would be very difficut to see and could go beyond your 5200 bead on the inside.

As you have said...... The tubes are only 14 bucks. Just do it over.

If you have lost the o-rings, the flare was never right. You could 5200 them in there..... But they would be very hard to get out when they go bad again (and they will). You could damage the openings in the hull and the gel coat if you use too much 5200.

AJ

Posted by kevin nolan on 04/05/06 - 5:08 PM
#13

I don't know. I used 5200 and don't know if I should take it out. But if I do, should I cut of the flared end and cut both inside and out to the proper angle and then add 5/16 to each side, put on the orings then flare both sides? Why does the tube come with one side flared its at a 45 degree angle and nieither inside or out is at 45 degrees?

Edited by Tom W Clark on 04/05/06 - 10:20 PM

Posted by kevin nolan on 04/05/06 - 6:39 PM
#14

Sorry, is it 5/16" overall or for each side like if I measure the tube at each side in and out I should add 5/16" or 5/16" to each end? I'm going to cut both ends of the tube each at an angle to match the inside and outside. Sorry to sound repetitive but more information is better than not enough. Thanks so much to you all.

Kevin

Edited by Tom W Clark on 04/05/06 - 8:47 PM

Posted by Tom W Clark on 04/05/06 - 10:26 PM
#15

Kevin,

I don't know what you mean when you are describing a 45 degree angle. The drain tubes in Whalers more often than not do NOT come out of the hull perpendicular to it, but they rarely are angled more than 5 degrees or so from perpendicular. The most severe angle I have ever measured was 13 degrees in the bow sump drain tube in a 22.

Yes, I would pre-flare one side on the tube at an angle top match the hull, then slide the tube through (with an O-ring in place under the flare) and then scribe and cut the other end so it ends up 5/16" beyond the hull.

You then anneal that end, butter up both ends with 5200 and pop the other O-ring on and then flare the other end. Clean up the mess and you're good to go.

Posted by litespeed on 04/06/06 - 7:51 AM
#16

Oops.....

I forgot to post this with the above photo.

This is a pic of the finished PVC drain (outside). The "caulk bead" is much smaller becuase the hole was not damaged.

I painted the 5200 with bottom paint to keep the critters away.

The boat has been out every day for almost a week. Works like a champ!!

AJ

Posted by kevin nolan on 04/06/06 - 5:29 PM
#17

The tube comes flared at one end. It's a 45 degree angle. I'm going to cut the flare off. How do you flare just one end if there is no flared end and you cut both sides at an angle? The flaring tool flares both end at the same time. Thanks again, you're a lot of help. I'm glad I found this site. Sunday is the day I retry this. I hope I do OK. I think I will. Thanks a lot.

Kevin

Edited by Tom W Clark on 04/06/06 - 5:39 PM

Posted by litespeed on 04/07/06 - 3:54 PM
#18

Ok,

I finally finished the PVC motor well drain today. I have been putting it off for a week. Only took about 30 minutes and I found out that the old drain was copper and was leaking:o. O-rings had dry rotted, caulk was gone and the tube was compromised.

Luckily the wood was still pretty dry:).

Here are some pics of preping the PVC drains. This was a very tight fit and turned out well. I had to tap the PVC in with a hammer to make the marks for cutting. I could have made it look better. But, I was in a hurry.

Still turned out real nice:D.

AJ

Posted by litespeed on 04/07/06 - 3:57 PM
#19

Here is the outside motor well PVC drain ready for 5200. Very tight fit!

AJ

Posted by litespeed on 04/07/06 - 4:00 PM
#20

Here is a shot of both PVC drains finished.

This turned out real nice. I can remove and replace them both in about 1 hour flat (if I need to).

Piece of cake. The PVC stuff is easy to find, easy to work with and easy to install.

Enjoy,

AJ

Posted by Riptide23WA on 04/13/06 - 7:41 PM
#21

Nice work AJ. I was thinking about this very same solution a few days ago, and tonight I stumbled across your thread. I am slated to pick up an old 13 later this spring, and I will probably be replacing the drain tubes as well.

I have been wanting to ask you about your Awlgrip. Did you do it yourself? That is a beautiful boat you have now. Makes me antsy to get going on mine...

Thanks Pat

Posted by litespeed on 04/14/06 - 8:51 AM
#22

Pat,

Welcome to the forum!

No, I did not do the paint myself... I wish I had the knowledge and equipment to do so. The shop that did the work is "A" Quality Fiberglass in Fort Pierce, FL. They had a hell of a time painting it. All the curves, corners and crevices made it extremely diffcult to get it perfect. But, they finally got it!

The beauty of this paint system is the lack of maintenance. It is literally maintenance free. No waxing, buffing or fading gelcoat. It will look just like it does now in 20 years.

If you do the drains... You will not regret it. I am amazed with the results. A little more sanding around the holes would have made beautiful caulk beads. I'm just ready to use the boat.

AJ

Posted by Riptide23WA on 04/14/06 - 8:45 PM
#23

AJ, is the Awlgrip really that much better than, say, a two-part Interlux that a DIY'er can apply? I have big plans for my little 13, and I'm only gonna get one shot at painting it, so I want to do it right. If you don't mind my asking, what did it cost to have it painted?

Posted by litespeed on 04/15/06 - 8:04 PM
#24

Pat,

PM was sent...

AJ

Edited by litespeed on 04/15/06 - 8:19 PM

Posted by litespeed on 05/15/06 - 8:36 AM
#25

Well the PVC Drain tubes have been in for almost 2 months now with no problems. I pulled the lower tube just to see if it was really dry in there.

Bone dry!!! As the day I sealed it. The 5200 really holds it in there and it was a little difficult to get out.

I reinstalled the tube with 5200 only arond the openings. It is pressed in there so there is not a need for very much.

The boat has seen heavy use. Getting used 4 to5 days a week with up to 3 days in the water at a time (tied to a dock). I also swamped the boat once to test its buoyancy. 2 people in it, all the gear and a full tank of gas there was only a couple inches of water in the boat.

I dont see there being any problem with these tubes. If they ever need to be replaced...... It only takes a few minutes to do it.

Regards,

AJ

Posted by Tim Gibbs on 06/03/06 - 4:49 PM
#26

What if you routed out some of the foam prior to installing the PVC and filled with WEST Epoxy with High Density filler. If any water did get by, it would cantact the epoxy and not the foam. I added a drain path in the port channel to the bait well under the deck of my 22 Revenge by drilling and routing out the foam. Mixing epoxy with filler, trowling it in the opening, then inflating a baloon through the hole to compress the epoxy mixture and keep it from sagging. Perhaps a similar process on the drain tubes then 5200 the PVC in.

Posted by litespeed on 06/12/06 - 4:02 PM
#27

Tim,

That is a good idea. I thought of that when I was working on the hull. This boat has already been wet inside once. I'm sure it will probably happen again. It is inevetable in this design.

These large holes are the reason the boat dried out so well. Set up like this it is pretty easy to air it out again (if I need to).

AJ

Posted by drandlett on 07/10/06 - 3:33 PM
#28

AJ,

I am now finding it time to replace my drain tubes on my 1968 whaler, and want to use your method. I have asked you many questions in previous months but am just now able to get working on my boat. I understand the process except the first step. How do you get the existing brass tube out of the hull?

Thank you,

Dana

Posted by litespeed on 07/14/06 - 8:44 AM
#29

drandlett wrote:
AJ,

I am now finding it time to replace my drain tubes on my 1968 whaler, and want to use your method. I have asked you many questions in previous months but am just now able to get working on my boat. I understand the process except the first step. How do you get the existing brass tube out of the hull?

Thank you,

Dana


To collapse the drain tube.... Carefully and lightly tap the inside flange with a small hammer and screwdriver. Tap it so it begins to fold like a taco. You may have to tap from several angles to collapse it enough so it will fit through the hole.

Once the tube is partially collapsed. Lightly tap the edge of the tube with a wooden dowel or the same screwdriver towards the rear of the boat. You want to drive the tube from the inside of the boat out the rear. I found the screwdriver was splitting the brass tube. So I used a small dowel to get it moving.

Once the tube comes out the rear about an inch or so you can grab the tube with a pair of pliers or Vice Grips and pull the rest of the way out.

Pretty easy. Take your time.

Just be careful not to damage the gelcoat or paint. If the boat has been painted or has bottom paint you will want to cut around the tubes with a razor knife so they move easier and do not peel the paint off when they start moving.

AJ

Posted by Chum on 06/02/15 - 7:39 AM
#30

An old thread with a good solution, does anyone know how to get the poster to update us on the results now years later?

Posted by mtown on 06/02/15 - 2:15 PM
#31

Hopefully you just did. The only problem I could possibly see with using pvc is that if water could lay in that tube it would fracture if it froze.
I would guess that the brass would do the same.

Whaler used the products available at the time. Plastic pipe was somewhat untested for something like this..
Plus sealants have advanced way beyond what was available 30 years ago, much less 50 years ago.

Posted by Chum on 06/03/15 - 6:39 PM
#32

I'm hoping he can post how it has worked now years later. Meanwhile to keep the thread interesting, here's some more information I found in my research, ie: it can be done with PVC pipe, and sealed with 5200 or with epoxy:

Gluing Plastic With G/flex Epoxy

http://www.westsystem.com/ss/gluing-p...lex-epoxy/

http://www.classicmako.com/forum/topi...C_ID=45287

Edited by Chum on 06/03/15 - 6:43 PM

Posted by Chum on 06/03/15 - 6:50 PM
#33

mtown wrote: The only problem I could possibly see with using pvc is that if water could lay in that tube it would fracture if it froze. I would guess that the brass would do the same.

Whaler used the products available at the time. Plastic pipe was somewhat untested for something like this..
Plus sealants have advanced way beyond what was available 30 years ago, much less 50 years ago.


There's now also pultruded fiberglass tubing, which could be used and is not that much money. It could be sealed with any thickened epoxy. $12 for a 8' tube of 1.25" OD, 1/8" wall, which should be a perfect 1" ID fit. http://www.mgs4u.com/fiberglass-tube-...be-rod.htm

Edited by Chum on 06/03/15 - 6:52 PM

Posted by mtown on 06/04/15 - 5:38 AM
#34

That fiberglass tubing is what was used by Blackfin for exhaust pipes. I had a 1978 with gas inboard and that was what was installed from the factory. It ran out either side of the transom and one side had a very slight drip in an inaccessible spot. I sleeved schedule 40 PVC pipe inside the fiberglass, used high heat silicone at the small gap where the two ended at the transom and ran that boat for 12 more years with no leaks at all.