Thread subject: Whaler Central - Boston Whaler Boat Information and Photos :: Assigning value to BW17SS after accident cause by others

Posted by cpe2385 on 06/15/15 - 1:25 PM
#1

I was involved in a wreck over the weekend where my 1984 17' SS with 1984 Evinrude 90, our trailer and thus our tow vehicle were rear ended. Everyone was ok. The car that rear ended us has to be totaled. Our trailer will likely be totaled, our whaler will require a significant amount of gelcoat work, potentially some fiberglass work (hoping no structural issues arise) and our motor withstood a reasonable impact but appears to be ok.

I know what I paid and I know what NADA quotes the boat and motor to be worth.
My question is this:
How do I assign a true replacement value on an antique boat that is just about irreplaceable?
A similar question for the motor- I could find a comparable used motor but would lack a knowledge of maintenance, condition and reliability. How can I assign value to the motor?

Ultimately, I want the trailer replaced, boat repaired and a new motor. I also think that is reasonable given how important reliability is when on the water. I want to have all the information at hand so as to prevent the insurance company from "totaling" the whole package.

Ya'lls input is always invaluable.
Thanks,