---

"I do plan on fishing from it..."

If the choice is only between a new Montauk 150, or a new 170 Super Sport, and fishing is a big part of your plans for the boat, then the Montauk 150 is the better option.

But I also agree with the previous post about comparing with a used Montauk 170. And, based on the budget you have for a new Montauk 150, I would also suggest that some other models are worthy of consideration too.

Almost a year ago, I began my search for a Whaler. I initially narrowed it down to a new Montauk 170 (after also considering a new Montauk 150.) However, due to other factors, the timing wasn't right and I had to wait a bit before pulling the trigger. In the intervening months, I continued to research and learn more about the Whaler offerings.

Over time, I became aware of two other used models in the size-range I was looking at, both of which offered additional features and capability: Outrage 17 I, and Outrage 18/19 II. I ended up with an Outrage 19 II, and am pleased to have it (at about half the price of a new Montauk 170.)

I guess I'm suggesting that you take your time and get familiar with the various models, and see if there might be something that is a better fit to your plans and budget. Worst case you simply confirm that the Montauk 150 is the right boat for you.