---

There is no comparison then.

It depends on whether you want the Classic hull of the Montauk or the newer Accutrack hull of the Outrage 17' II.

I have owned both.
I moved up from the Montauk 17' to the Outrage 17' II because the Montauk had a much rougher ride.
I found out that I liked the Classic look so I sold the Outrage 17' II and bought the Classic Outrage 18'.
Here is the fleet I had to choose from.
http://users.sisqtel.net/jkriz/Outrag...fleet.html

Owning the 3 boats at the same time, we found that every time we went boating, we ended up taking out the Outrage 18'.

You can do a search here on this site for more info.
If your tow vehicle can tow the Outrage 17' II, and you like the non-Classic look, then the Outrage 17' II might be the choice.